Menu Close

What’s wrong with our political system?

We rightly have reasonable expectations that living in a democracy provides for the protection of citizens’ rights which includes that citizens actively participate in shaping society. The many dangers now facing us, environmental, economic and social show that our present system is not working.  How can Citizen Assemblies change this?

Here you can compare the dismal problems with the current political process and how these can be corrected by Citizen Assemblies. Click on the button for each topic to toggle between how things are now, and what they could be like if we used citizen assemblies effectively.

Current political process
Citizen Assembly

There is an ever-growing disconnect between representatives and voters.
Politicians cannot fully reflect the views, needs, or priorities of the people they represent. Once elected, towing the party line is hard to resist and personal interests can become conflated with those of voters.

Participants in a Citizen Assembly are selected directly from the electorate.
With a Citizen Assembly selected individuals from a pool of eligible and representative citizens address the issues as part of a facilitated process. The problems of party politics and loyalties are greatly reduced and issues can receive thorough and honest consideration.

Current political process
Citizen Assembly

The corrupting influence of money and lobbying
Campaign financing and lobbying by wealthy individuals, corporations and interest groups greatly influence politicians. This has skewed policies in favor of the powerful over the general public, eroding trust in the system and creating policies that benefit a minority and disadvantage the majority.

It is almost impossible for lobbyists or business interests to manipulate the participants or capture the process.

Current political process
Citizen Assembly

A mass media dominated by poorly researched material, entertaining rather than informing, with bias towards corporate interests.
Biased or sensationalist media shapes public opinion and pushes certain agendas and this affects decision making. When voters are misinformed or only exposed to polarizing news, they may make choices that don’t serve their best interests or their communities.

Media influence and lobbying have no direct access to a Citizen Assembly.
While media influence may affect the views of members of the public, inside a Citizen Assembly everyone is on an equal footing. The facilitated process provides an atmosphere of constructive listening from which everyone benefits. It is common that even long-held positions may be moderated towards greater appreciation of other views.

Current political process
Citizen Assembly

Loss of confidence by voters, especially the young
When people feel their vote won’t make a difference or are dissatisfied with the limited and poor choices available, they disengage.

Citizen Assemblies are opportunities for direct participation by all age groups.
Participants become deeply engaged with the issues under discussion, and their considerations also inform the wider public. Citizen Assemblies help create a broader appreciation of the potential breadth and complexity of the issues.

Current political process
Citizen Assembly

Polarization and partisan gridlock
Extreme leads to gridlock, where little to no meaningful policy decisions are made. This results in political deadlock, with representatives more focused on blocking with opposition and not working collaboratively. Important issues languish unresolved.

A facilitated Citizen Assembly encourages listening, learning and cooperation.
Each Citizen Assembly is always a fresh undertaking. People previously unacquainted meet and are encouraged to share their experience and wisdom, and to listen to that of their fellow participants. While a 100% consensus may not be achieved, enough is usually reached for agreed recommendations to emerge. In addition, the participants invariably leave with greater understanding and acceptance of other views.

Current political process
Citizen Assembly

Short-term focus due to election cycles
Representatives often focus on policies that yield immediate, visible, personal benefits to secure re-election. This is at the expense of long-term planning and investment in issues like infrastructure, education, and climate change. This short-term focus undermines policies that require consistent, long-term commitment.

Citizen Assemblies have no election cycles.
Without the prospect of being elected for a subsequent Citizen Assembly there is no incentive to consider continuing political power.

Current political process
Citizen Assembly

Weak accountability mechanisms
When accountability is weak, representatives can act with impunity, knowing there are few consequences for failing to serve their constituents' interests. Corruption, lack of transparency, and inadequate checks on power all weaken accountability and make representatives less motivated to fulfill their duties, leaving citizens to suffer unnecessarily.

The open process and direct participation give us better accountability
The accountability for the decisions made by government is based on the published recommendations of the Assembly.

A Citizen Assembly is held accountable externally by the integrity of the transparent selection process and internally by the collective, co-operative, social conscience that is well understood in jury deliberations.